Walker Thought His Business Tax Break Would Stimulate The Economy. The Early Returns Aren’t Good.

Aaron Rupar

Aaron Rupar ThinkProgress

In 2011 — the same year Scott Walker became governor — Wisconsin enacted a Manufacturing and Agriculture Credit (MAC) meant to stimulate the state economy by providing tax relief for those who use property for productive purposes. A new study indicates it’s providing lots of tax relief for the rich but not much economic stimulus for anybody else.

The Wisconsin Budget Project study finds that MAC is taking a much greater toll on the state budget than lawmakers envisioned. Though it was initially estimated that the credit would reduce tax collections by $129 million in fiscal year 2017, the Wisconsin Department of Revenue now estimates it’ll cost $284 million next year. That’s roughly $30 million more than the amount Walker and the Republican-controlled legislature cut from the University of Wisconsin System in 2015.

The study also finds that MAC disproportionately benefits the rich and has had a negligible impact on job creation. Tax filers who make $1 million or more received 78 percent of the total credit amount this year, while those who make less than $300,000 got just seven percent. In return for that massive tax giveaway to the wealthy, Wisconsin’s manufacturing sector, which receives five out of every six MAC dollars, has actually shrunk relative to the rest of the state’s economy.

And Wisconsin’s manufacturing sector hasn’t grown significantly relative to the rest of the country either. In the five years since MAC was implemented, Wisconsin has ranked 25th among the 50 states in manufacturing sector job growth.

Furthermore, the Wisconsin Budget Project study points out that a claimant need not create jobs to qualify for MAC tax breaks. As long as they’re using property productively, a claimant could lay off workers or shift operations to other states and still qualify for relief.

Jason Culotta, senior director of government relations for Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce, argues that the 34,000 manufacturing jobs created in the state since 2011 is evidence MAC is working. But Wisconsin Budget Project analyst Tamarine Cornelius counters that the numbers suggest the same amount of jobs might’ve been created without the massive tax giveaway.

“We’re pretty close to the national average (for manufacturing job growth) before the credit and we’re pretty close the national average after the credit,” Cornelius said, according to a Wisconsin Public Radio report. “What are we getting for this very large tax credit, that’s mostly going to the pockets of not just the wealthy but the very, very wealthy, if not jobs? What is the benefit to the rest of Wisconsin?”

This isn’t the first time Walker has generated negative headlines for providing tax subsidies for job creation, a tactic that multiple studies have shown is counterproductive.

Last year, Wisconsin’s non-partisan Legislative Audit Bureau issued a damning report about the Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation, a job creation agency set up by Walker. The report found that the agency, which provides taxpayer dollars to private corporations to help them create jobs, failed to follow up on whether the companies were actually using the funds for job creation, gave loans and tax credits to companies that did not meet its requirements, and didn’t even attempt to fact-check claims by the companies about the number of jobs they created, among other problems.


This has been reposted from Think Progress.

Aaron Rupar comes to ThinkProgress from Minnesota, where he was established as a staff writer for the Minneapolis City Pages covering everything from crime to state politics to cultural news and back again. He also worked as a digital producer for the Twin Cities Fox TV affiliate and as a communications staffer for the Democratic caucus in the Minnesota House of Representatives. Outside the newsroom, Aaron enjoys NBA basketball (particularly the Minnesota Timberwolves) and all sorts of live music. He's an accomplished jazz and rock n' roll drummer who's looking to network with musicians in DC, so if you know of a playing opportunity or news tip, please drop him a line. Aaron has a masters degree in philosophy from the University of Minnesota.

Posted In: Allied Approaches

Stronger Together

Stronger Together